Jonathan Steele
Thursday July 6, 2006
The Guardian
Thank goodness for the Swiss. Alone in Europe, their government has dared to condemn what the Israelis are doing to Gaza. It is collective punishment, they say. It violates the principle of proportionality. Israel has not taken the precautions required by international law to protect civilians.
Inevitably, the bloggers are pouring out the usual irrelevancies about the role of Swiss banks during the Nazi period. But as the depository of the Geneva conventions, one of the key legal advances to emerge from the ravages of the 20th century, Switzerland has a duty to speak out
Its statement stands in contrast to the European Union's shamefully muted voice. The Palestinians kill two soldiers and take one prisoner and, in response, power stations are blown up, sewage and water systems grind to a halt, bridges are destroyed, sonic booms terrify children day and night, and all this is inflicted on a hungry people who are under siege in what is effectively a huge open prison. The EU's response? Vague expressions of "concern" and calls for "restraint".
Jonathan dear boy, you may be blind to the fact that Israel vacated the Gaza strip to the Palestinians who moved in and right away began firing Kassam rockets (over 40 a day) at Israeli civilians, killing and maiming many. Further, the Palestinians fired the rockets near civilians, in effect using them as human shields. All of this in violation of the Geneva conventions you cite. You conveniently leave all of this out in pointing out the reasons for Israels response.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment